Saturday, January 06, 2007

Firemen In The Education Department

I've sent this article to The Star, The Sun, and News Straits Times. Just in case it doesn't make it in the press.


********************

Our Education Department must have acquired secret training from the Fire Department. They operate under the same modus operandi. They go to work only after there is a fire.

I wonder if anyone had foreseen that it was only a matter of time before saturation point is reached, considering the constant mass production of education graduates. Did anyone think about making statistical checks to meet the supply of teachers with the demand for them?

Education graduates from local universities of 2006 have finished their studies in May 2006. The new year has greeted them. But up to this day, even Kementerian Pendidikan Malaysia’s (KPM) scholarship holders have not yet received their posting.

Letters were sent from the Education Department, appealing for patience. No date of expectancy was given. The Education Department has to understand that when houses are on fire, telling the victims to wait is not a comforting response.

Yes, they have been quite letter-happy alright. Letters were sent out in October 2006 to all Education graduates to call for an interview. Some did not receive a letter at all. When checked, their names were “not on the list.”

The unreliability of Education Department’s database was further amplified when a UKM education graduate received two interview letters. One letter said the interview will be on the November 14, the other said November 15.

KPM scholarship holders received the same interview letter too. They went all the way to attend their interview on the given date, only to be sent back before the interview began. It was an admitted mistake that KPM scholarship holders should’ve been rightfully exempted from an interview.

Did I mention that the interview letters were sent via Pos Ekspress? The Education Department must’ve used a lot of taxpayer’s money to fight fires. Normal mail would have sufficed if they were a tad more efficient. In fact, millions of Ringgit would’ve been saved in retraining teachers, sending letters, and pumping money in all the wrong places. But I guess they have a lot of financial aid from the NEP to pull it off.

Speaking of financial aid, did you know that KPM scholarship holders were given RM26,000 to complete their degree, and they are bonded for 4 years of government service? KPM scholarship holders are required to serve the government within 12 months after finishing their degree. I guess the government is really pushing it. The government is not giving scholarship holders a chance to do their dues, and the scholarship contract makes them unable to find a job elsewhere during that period of time.

What are education graduates to do? In my opinion, KPM scholarship holders can go ahead and look for a permanent job in the corporate sector. And if they do get a posting after they already found a job, they can ask the government to release them from the bond. It’s not as though the government has not wasted taxpayer’s money before. And I’m sure hundreds of graduate teachers will be more than willing to take up their places.

On 29th October 2006, the press quoted Prof Zakaria, UPM Dean of Educational Studies saying, “there is no obligation for the government to hire them.” My question is this. If the government is not obligated to employ education graduates, how come teachers are not trained to function outside the four walls of a classroom throughout their 4 years of university education? The government is just wiping their hands clean. If graduate teachers add to the number of unemployment in the country, they are indeed victims of circumstances caused by the government.

I personally wouldn’t want to see the day when I look back in retrospect and say, “The years I spent in pursuit of my aspirations to be a teacher was a total waste of time.”

Here’s wishing a productive new year to our firemen in the Education Department. Time to strap on rubber boots and get to work. Fire has broken out.

13 comments:

Anonymous said...

I really doubt your letter will see the light of day in AAB's media. I think Lim Kit Siang (http://blog.limkitsiang.com), Jeff Ooi (http://www.jeffooi.com) and Raja Petra Kamarudin (www.malaysia-today.net) will be more likely to publish your letter and help you with it esp. LKS.

Rgds,
buzzer.

Anonymous said...

i agree. go approach the above mentioned and true uncle LKS will alert the KPM.
sdasir

Anonymous said...

hey joshua =)

good piece, very well written.

about education graduates not being prepared for life outside school tho, i'd like to point out something that i only found out recently:

in Universiti Sabah, education graduates study to get a degree in education, with [subject]. like education with science, or education with physics, or whatever. whereas in most other unis, as far as i know, they study to get a degree in [subject]with education. the difference is, with a degree in education the graduate has no choice but to teach; whereas with a degree in [subject] with education, the graduate has the option to find an occupation which applies his/her knowledge in said subject.

this was told to me by a friend who appealed for a transfer from Universiti Sabah to UM because of this. she didn't want to be pigeonholed into education and then left in the lurch by government stupidity.

yeah, so, the picture might not be so simple. =)

siehjin

Anonymous said...

The Sun continues to live up to its 'upstart' credentials as compared to the other papers...Hopefully it'll be picked up within this week. I think you got published in the hard copy cos you certainly got coverage on the Net (http://www.sun2surf.com/article.cfm?id=16606)

All the best,
buzzer.

Hasten said...

Buzzer: It did come out in hard copy. Yesterday, NST, page 28. Today, The Sun, picture on front page, story on page 8.

I think I just kissed government schools goodbye and burnt the bridges!

Anonymous said...

It was nice knowing you. I'll get the daisies. :)

akmj said...

hi joshua!
found ur blog thru links :)
i'm waiting for posting too, am a KPM scholarship holder. and nope, i didn't receive any letter regarding any interview. But i did receive a letter from MOHE bout some polytechnic / community college post. So now i'm confused, along with a few of my coursemates (who also received our letter)... Have we been "sold" to MOHE, or are we still attached with MOE? Coz we also got the letter from MOE asking us to be patient...

tell me when u get ur posting ya? would be nice to get in touch with other christian teachers...

Hasten said...

Angela: Are you a university graduate, or a maktab or UPSI graduate?

You can always call up the education ministry to clarify things.

If I were you, I'll just take up the job.

Anonymous said...

The discontent rages on...

http://www.nst.com.my/Current_News/nst/Thursday/Letters/20070111082905/Article/index_html

Hasten said...

Great! Let me know if there are any responses in The Sun also, k. Thanks.

Anonymous said...

A small little word of congratulation from this guy, before going off onto various other topics: http://www.sun2surf.com/article.cfm?id=16644

Congratulations on your article "Is there really a shortage of teachers?" (Jan 9) about a graduate teacher who has waited four months for a posting. Here is a Mathematics graduate ready to serve and pay back his loan and yet a professor says the government is not obligated to hire graduates such as him.

akmj said...

"Angela: Are you a university graduate, or a maktab or UPSI graduate?"

Does it really matter? (",) Anyway, i graduated from UTM's TESL...

Oh ya, the letter i mentioned earlier, was just a letter requesting for our transcript and SPM results :)

Anyway, 8 of us from UTM just received our posting last thursday, reporting for work on Tuesday 16th January... I got Politeknik Johor Bahru.

hey, don't worry, u'll definitely get urs, since u're a scholarship holder. Many of my coursemates are also waiting. I think you'll get it this month itself... Be prepared to pack ur bags IN A RUSH and GO!!!! hehehehe...

Hasten said...

Angela: I think it does. KPLI people get first priority. UPSI graduates are next. University graduates are given last priority.

Anyway, when it comes to government consistency, I dare not postulate anything.

5 days to pack and go, huh. That's very kind of them.

Anyway, great to know you're starting today! I'm sure you're very excited. All the best :)