Monday, June 11, 2007

Why cannot chor tai dee?

Where does it say in the Bible that it is wrong to gamble?

No where.

So, why do we get so uptight about gambling? Why do we say it’s wrong to gamble with card games during Chinese New Year? Why do we say it’s wrong to go to casinos? Why do we say it’s not right to buy lottery tickets? Isn’t the stock market a form of legalized gambling?

Actually, we don’t have to get legalistic about this. The principle is very simple. It can be found no further than the second commandment.

“You shall have no other gods before Me.” (Exodus 20:3).

You see, it basically boils down to a matter of greed. If the activity of gambling facilitates our greed, then our greed will lead to idolatry. Money becomes the god that occupies our heart.

Back to the Chinese New Year thing. Why is it that we can’t gamble? Gambling with only a few cents won’t hurt, will it? What if we use peanuts? What’s a few bucks, as long as I don’t raise the stakes above RM2 per round?

The question is not the amount of the bet. The question is, why bet at all? If the stakes are too small, it wouldn’t hurt if you lose. It wouldn’t be pleasurable if you win. It is too small to have any significance in any way, isn’t it?

So why bet at all? Play it for free, purely for pleasure.

Ah… Then it’s not so fun anymore, isn’t it? Admit it. Placing a bet, however small, made all the difference.

So, what if I limit myself to just small bets? Having little pleasures in life wouldn’t hurt, will it?

Yeah, true. But you see, human tolerance for pleasure is stretchable. The small things that once brought pleasure won’t be pleasurable anymore after some time. You’ll want bigger pleasures. You’ll want to place bigger bets to get the same effect.

Hence, down the slippery slope we go. Soon, we can no longer tell the difference whether we’re playing it for pleasure, or to fulfill an addiction.

Before we know it, we’ll be just too ready to pull out a deck of cards with some coins on the table to while away our time. “Just for pleasure,” we’ll say. Yeah, just small bets. Yeah, just for the next 10 minutes. While waiting for lunch. While waiting for the bus. While waiting for dinner, which won’t be ready until the next 3 hours.

And we wonder why we carry our deck of cards with us all day long. Soon, to maintain the same level of pleasure, the stakes are raised.

From pleasure, to addiction. From addiction, to greed. From greed, to idolatry. If you can't tell where it leads, why start at all? Same applies to visiting casinos, buying lottery tickets, and playing with stocks unwisely. Morally wrong, principally incorrect.

However, there was this incident that blurred the lines a little.

My father shared this incident that happened to a Burmese man. His church has a ministry for foreign workers, and they have a group of Burmese there. They work as rough laborers in Malaysia. The church looks after them and gives them support in any practical way they can.

The foreign workers pay their agents thousands of Ringgit just to get into Malaysia. These men left their wives and children in Myanmar, and came to Malaysia to work, hoping to make a better living. With the little that they have, they send it back to their wives and children. Often, they have close to nothing left for food. They don’t have medical allowances when they fall sick. It would take them many years just to pay back their agents. What more to make a decent living in Malaysia.

One day, my father got a phonecall. “Saya kena loteri!” The Burmese guy said. He won RM10,000! He doesn’t have a Malaysian IC, so he needed someone to get the prize money on his behalf. He asked his boss to do it for him. But his boss wanted a commission of RM2,000. Having no one else to trust, he turned to my father.

So, my father went to the lottery shop, took out the money, and gave it to the Burmese guy and his friends. My father asked for nothing in return. But the Burmese insisted my father to accept an envelope of thanks from them. Inside it, RM500.

Almost immediately, the Burmese sent the money back to their families. After that, they had a really fun day. Just basic fun on food, drinks and small luxuries of life. And yeah, they were happy that day.
Really happy.

Well, on one hand, my father told them it was not right to gamble. One can go on to present the whole set of arguments on why it is wrong to buy lottery tickets. Encouraged by this win, they may go on to buy lottery tickets from every lottery company, every day of the week. That’s not gonna be the right path to go by.

Morally wrong? Yes. Principally incorrect? Yes.

But as for the Burmese, somehow I felt happy for them. That day, somebody’s wife in a far away place had some money to live by. Some children could buy food to eat. Some family member could see a doctor and sleep well that night. That day, somebody who lived a lifetime of hardship tasted a short time of happiness.

In the light of compassion, sometimes certain rules can get blurred.

11 comments:

akmj said...

Once a very close friend of mine in varsity (a Christian) was really broke as our scholarship money was late. So she actually prayed and asked God for the 'permission' to buy 4D just that one time, and asked God to let her win some money to live on.

Guess what?

She won some money.

God is compassionate.

:)

Of course, that was the one and only time she gambled.

Anonymous said...

Well, issue of gambling or merely having fun. during CNY, all relatives come back and have fun with a game of card where the stakes are RM1. No hard and fast rule.

Let me share my experience. During CNY, i can be the "holier than thou" and refrain from such adtivities. Alwiz drawing the line. keeping away frm the sinner. whats the point? what do i achieve at the end? Nothing, just more separation. Sending msg like yeah la, we're the jolly sinners la and u're the church ppl.

Or i can join in the fun. Talk about crap, family stuff and get to understand them better. Ppl talk a lot over such games and warm up very well. Then they tend to tell u more personal stuff later. Usually after game, we go for a meal. Thats where things get nice and warm.

Compare to holy joe, i tell myself, its ok. Loose loose la. Afterall, whats a few bucks compared to bonding and building brigdes. U sometimes really get to do it once a year (i mean bonding). What kinda testimony is this? Well, its sometimes practical.

Liquor is another issue. Ppl talk more.... hehehe.... but well, my stand is NO. Ppl manipulate this too much.

-Kenny

Anonymous said...

Hey all. Just came across this blog. The key point is to be realistic and practical in our way of life as Christians. Reach out to the marketplace, and get "dirty". Better than hiding ourselves in our "holy shells". We can do our part, wherever and whenever. So long as we stay strong to our root and foundation - our God.

akmj said...

wow. kenny and siew yin: your comments have made me think and look deeper into this issue.

Hasten said...

I've been following the Star's Merdeka Celebrations contest. Want to win RM10,000. Greedy. Hehehe...

siehjin said...

another angle to look at this is the 'don't stumble your bro' angle.

gambling may not be wrong for me cos i'm not gambling for money, just for fun, and for all the noble reasons like wanting to bond wth ppl and etc. but what if a younger christian brother sees me gambling, thinks it's ok, and gets addicted to it as per joshua's slippery slope?

no hard and fast rules, i guess. but another aspect of the question to be pondered.

Hasten said...

Some would argue against the "don't stumble your brother" angle by saying that we're holding ourselves captive by our own paranoia, always thinking that there's always somebody watching who may be stumbled... When that isn't always the case. What about Christian liberty? Yada yada yada...

Also, some would argue that a "slippery slope" is actually a type of fallacy in reasoning, i.e. just because you did step 1 doesn't necessarily mean it will lead to step 2, 3, 4 and 5. Why assume that you cannot do step 1 and stop there? Yada yada yada...

Anonymous said...

When i was a younger Christian in faith and age, I use to think how come dad gamble when the bible teach me cannot gamble ar?

I found out when i was old enough to understand what all these means. Only for fun and bonding? The only time i saw him taking RM1 and put it on stakes is during CNY. Well I dont tag along everywhere he goes but i know him well enough that yup its only during CNY.

Did it stumble me as a kid then? Well it made me ask questions and seek my faith deeper. I guess its only when a bro/sis is young at faith that it will stumble them. But its also their part to look deeper than skin deep. Oh he gamble... bad christian. Then it would be judging the other.

Well i wont go to a youth camp and open table and lets chor tai dee. Thats ignorance and foolish, outright stumbling. But its on one hand the younger faith bro/sis to eat meat and grow in his faith and its the other to teach the truth about this.


-Kenny

siehjin said...

actually, i've played chor tai dee at youth camps before. it's not a problem, as long as there's no betting involved. it's just a card game, after all.

if u say cannot chor tai dee, might as well say cannot play football. after all, ppl bet money on world cup games wat. that's gambling.

Hasten said...

My chor tai dee days were learnt at the swimming pool.

When we go for national meets, we got nothing much to do while waiting for our events. So, to keep our minds off things and to keep relaxed...

"Lai lai lai... Phak kau, gia chut lai..."

Anonymous said...

Great Blog!! We should buy lottery tickets to entertain ourselves and get rid of all the stress from our life..Buy lottery tickets and win amazing prizes!!!